Is Excel dead? This podcast episode is a head-to-head debate on whether Excel still has a place in finance, recorded after months of heated online arguments about new software replacing spreadsheets. Listen to both sides and decide where Excel fits in your own finance stack.
Following many heated debates online, fake news, software company bashing and a challenge to debate the topic, Chris Argent and Lance Rubin took to a few rounds to spar it out.
Enjoy the discussion or listen in on your phone.
Is Excel dead? Frequently asked questions
To automate the repeatable parts of modelling, we built EXL Cloud, our own SaaS modelling platform: driver-based 3-way models in Excel, connected to Xero, with a library of Claude skills that help build, check and report on the model while the modeller keeps control of the logic.
Is Excel dead for finance professionals?
No. Spreadsheets remain the most widely used tool for financial modelling, analysis and reporting in finance teams. What has changed is what sits around them: Power Query, Power BI, cloud planning tools and AI now handle work spreadsheets were never designed for, such as large datasets and multi-user workflows. The practical answer is to use each tool for what it does best.
What are the biggest limitations of spreadsheets for finance teams?
Spreadsheets struggle when used as a database, shared by many users at once or relied on for version control. Large transaction volumes slow them down, manual copy-and-paste processes introduce errors, and complex workbooks become hard to audit. These limits are why many teams move data storage and consolidation into databases or BI tools while keeping spreadsheets for modelling and analysis.
Will AI replace spreadsheets?
AI is changing how people build and use spreadsheets rather than replacing them. AI assistants can now write formulas, explain workbooks and draft analysis, which makes modelling more accessible. Finance professionals still need to understand the logic, check the outputs and own the decisions, so modelling skills remain valuable alongside AI tools.
What should finance professionals learn beyond the basics?
Start with modern features such as dynamic arrays, LAMBDA, tables and Power Query, then add Power BI for reporting and data visualisation. A recognised financial modelling standard helps you build models others can audit. Data literacy and basic AI tooling round out the skill set, so you can choose the right tool for each task rather than forcing everything into one workbook.
When should a business move beyond spreadsheets?
Consider other tools when spreadsheets are used as databases, when several people need to update the same file, or when month-end reporting depends on manual copy and paste. Those are signs that data storage, consolidation or reporting belongs in a database, planning tool or BI platform. Spreadsheets can still sit on top for analysis and modelling.
Need a financial model built or reviewed for your business? See our Financial and Business Modelling services.
About the Author
Lance Rubin is CEO and Founder of Model Citizn, and founder and Chief Excel Officer of EXL Cloud, the SaaS platform that connects Xero to Excel with driver-based financial models, dashboards and Claude AI skills. He is a Chartered Accountant, FMI Certified Trainer, co-author of the CA ANZ Financial Modelling Study Guide, and creator of the AI-Powered Accountant programme on Maven, currently live at Level 1 with Level 2 in design, and author of the companion book “AI-Powered Accounting with Excel and Power BI” (Packt). He has worked at PwC, KPMG, Investec, and NAB, and is based in Melbourne, Australia.
Related reading: LAMBDA – The New Excel Paradigm for Modeling and How Dynamic Arrays are Revolutionising Financial Modelling.

