Excel remains the most widely used tool for financial modelling because it is flexible, transparent and understood by almost every finance professional. Financial modelling software adds structure, collaboration and controls, but at a cost in flexibility and licence fees. For most businesses, model design matters more than the tool.
Every few years a new wave of financial modelling software promises to replace the spreadsheet. Excel is still here, and it now sits alongside Power Query, Power BI and AI assistants that make it more capable than ever. Whichever tool you choose, the steps to build a financial model stay the same.
This article compares financial modelling software with Excel, explains where each fits and sets out the questions to answer before you change tools.
Key terms
- Financial modelling software: Dedicated applications for building forecasts and models, often with fixed structures, workflow and permissions.
- Spreadsheet risk: The risk of errors in spreadsheet models, usually caused by poor structure, hardcoding and lack of checks.
- Modelling standard: Rules for structure, formatting and formulas that make models consistent and auditable.
- Microsoft stack: Excel for modelling, Power Query for data and Power BI for reporting.

What are the advantages of Excel for financial modelling?
Excel’s advantages are flexibility, transparency, low cost and familiarity. Any business logic can be modelled, every formula can be traced, and almost every finance professional, lender and investor can open and review the file. With Power Query and Power BI, Excel models can also pull actuals automatically and feed interactive reporting.
What are the advantages of financial modelling software?
Financial modelling software offers built-in structure, multi-user collaboration, version control, permissions and audit trails. These matter when many contributors feed one plan, when there are several entities to consolidate, or when strict controls are required. The trade-off is less flexibility, licence and implementation costs, and logic that can be harder to inspect.
How do Excel and financial modelling software compare?
| Excel (well structured) | Financial modelling software | |
|---|---|---|
| Flexibility | Very high | Limited to the tool’s structure |
| Transparency | Every formula visible | Logic often hidden in configuration |
| Collaboration | Limited without extra tools | Strong, multi-user |
| Controls and audit trail | Depends on discipline | Built in |
| Cost | Low | Licences plus implementation |
| Skills availability | Widespread | Tool-specific |
Is spreadsheet risk a reason to switch?
Spreadsheet risk is real, but it is mostly a design problem rather than a tool problem. Hardcoded numbers, inconsistent formulas and missing checks cause the errors. A model built to a recognised standard, with inputs separated from calculations and a checks sheet, removes most of that risk. Moving a badly designed model into new software usually moves the problems with it.
When does financial modelling software make sense?
Financial modelling software makes sense when many people must contribute to the same plan at once, when you consolidate many entities, or when you need workflow approvals and a full audit trail. Even then, define the model first: drivers, structure and outputs. Software should support a model you understand, not replace thinking about it.
Will AI make Excel obsolete for financial modelling?
No. AI is more likely to create more Excel than less. When people review, adjust and sign off numbers, the work still lands in a spreadsheet; what changes is how quickly that spreadsheet gets built.
Excel formulas are deterministic, giving the same answer every time, while AI outputs are probabilistic. That makes Excel the natural place to anchor AI-assisted work, because results can be traced and checked. We discuss this in why AI will create more Excel, not less.
We apply these standards in EXL Cloud, our own SaaS modelling platform: driver-based 3-way models in Excel, connected to Xero, with a library of Claude skills that help build, check and report on the model while a modeller keeps control of the logic.
Frequently asked questions
Is Excel still used for financial modelling?
Yes. Excel remains the most common tool for financial modelling in corporate finance, FP&A, banking and advisory work. Its flexibility and transparency suit models that need to reflect a specific business, and modern features such as Power Query, dynamic arrays and LAMBDA, plus Power BI for reporting, have extended what Excel-based models can do.
What is the best financial modelling software?
The best choice depends on your needs. Excel suits most models when it is well structured. Dedicated software suits large organisations with many contributors, several entities and strict workflow requirements. Before choosing a tool, define your model’s drivers, structure and outputs, then pick the option that supports them at a cost you can justify.
Is financial modelling software more accurate than Excel?
Not inherently. Accuracy depends on the quality of the assumptions and the design of the model. Software can reduce some errors by enforcing structure, but it cannot fix poor assumptions or a model that does not reflect the business. A well-built Excel model with error checks can be just as reliable.
Can AI build financial models in Excel?
AI assistants can now draft formulas, explain workbooks and speed up parts of a model build. They still need an experienced modeller to define the structure, check the logic and validate outputs. AI is best treated as a productivity tool within a disciplined modelling process, not a replacement for one.
How do I reduce spreadsheet risk in my financial models?
Follow a modelling standard: separate inputs, calculations and outputs, use one consistent formula per row, avoid hardcoded numbers, include a checks sheet with balance and reconciliation tests, document assumptions and have important models independently reviewed. These steps reduce errors far more than changing the software you model in.
Can Power BI replace Excel for financial modelling?
Not usually. Power BI is designed for reporting and interactive dashboards, while Excel is better suited to building the calculation logic of a financial model, such as drivers, schedules and three-way statements. Many finance teams use both: Excel for the model and Power BI to present its results to managers and boards.
Need a model built properly in Excel, or help deciding whether software fits? See our Financial and Business Modelling services, or explore EXL Cloud for structured Excel models.
Related reading: Excel is dead! and The implications of not following a modelling standard.
Further reference: Microsoft Excel help and learning.
About the Author
Lance Rubin is CEO and Founder of Model Citizn, and founder and Chief Excel Officer of EXL Cloud, the SaaS platform that connects Xero to Excel with driver-based financial models, dashboards and Claude AI skills. He is a Chartered Accountant, FMI Certified Trainer, co-author of the CA ANZ Financial Modelling Study Guide, and creator of the AI-Powered Accountant programme on Maven, currently live at Level 1 with Level 2 in design, and author of the companion book “AI-Powered Accounting with Excel and Power BI” (Packt). He has worked at PwC, KPMG, Investec, and NAB, and is based in Melbourne, Australia.

